Chemplate Materials SL (Chemplate) wins its patent suit against former Licensee Cedal Equipment SRL (Cedal) in Turin Court

12 November 2017

Cedal loses all rights to produce, commercialise, distribute, sell and/or
import any machine incorporating Chemplate’s Indubond-like technology

The Technology behind the Indubond Trademark, Chemplate’s Patented Inductive
Bonding Registration System, licensed to Cedal, has been ruled to be for the sole
benefit of Chemplate Materials SL. Cedal was found to be in violation of Chemplate’s
European Patent # EP1460880. Cedal is forbidden any involvement in two machine
types: the “Bonding 130” pin registered Inductive Bonding System, as well as the
Pinless 211 single drawer machine.
In addition, the court found that Cedal’s filing of Italian patents #s 1,378,457 and
1.383.504, describing technology belonging to Chemplate Materials, to be a violation of
Chemplate’s rights as delineated in their European Patent. As a result, Chemplate was
awarded the title of Cedal’s Italian Patents #s 1,378,457 and1.383.504.
Cedal must pay Chemplate Materials damages as well as two-thirds of Chemplate
Materials’ legal costs for the process and additional costs related to the appeal by
Cedal of the original ruling.
Cedal became a licensee of Chemplate’s Indubond Technology in 2005. Violations of
the license came to light in 2007. When it became clear to Chemplate that Cedal was
infringing on Chemplate's European patent, a law suit was filed in May of 2010. The
original suit was declared in Chemplate’s favor and the results of that suit were
published in the Italian Newspaper La Repubblica at the beginning of November this
year (see the attachment to this article).
Cedal began an appeals process in January of 2015 and lost that appeal in a decision
announced in August of 2016 and confirmed by the Court of Turin on the 12 th of
September 2016. Some of the details as set forth in the original decision of April 2014
were modified by the appeals court including an increase of the “per violation” penalty
set forth as 1000 EUR by the lower court to 5000 EUR by the appeals court and an
increase in the legal fees of Chemplate Materials that Cedal must pay as a result of the

Chemplate Cedal

Related Stories

EIPC Events view all events

Publications view all publications

  • WECC Report 2017


    WECC Global PCB Production Report For 2017 FREE of charge EIPC membership service A Product of the Partnership among the WECC Member Associations on Behalf of their Members in the Electronic Circuits Industry Worldwide

  • Proceedings EIPC 50th Anniversary Conference Dusseldorf


    Proceedings 50th Anniversary conference 2018

Industry Directory view directory

  • Cicor Group

    Cicor is a globally active group of leading companies in the electronics industry. The group’s companies provide complete outsourcing services and a broad range of technologies for the manufacture of highly complex PCBs, 3D-MID solutions, hybrids circuits, electronic modules, plastic injection molding and box-building.

  • Isola Group

    Corporate Responsibility. The responsible stewardship of the environment and sustainable business practices is important to long-term success. Committed to operating our business in a manner that creates better social, economic and environmental outcomes for all those involved in the electronics industry.


Please provide some more details


Please login or register


EIPC membership has many advantages, both financially and in services. Such as:


You must be a member to view this content


EIPC membership has many advantages, both financially and in services. Such as:


Please Login / Register


Please provide some more details

Please provide some more details

Thank you!

An EIPC staff member will contact you soon to arrange payment.

Please fill in the form

EIPC will send an invoice to you through email and discuss your yearly fees.